THN: "The OT Argument "

Lesedauer: ca. 3 Minuten

Die Titelstory der neuesten Ausgabe der nordamerikanischen Fachzeitschrift "The Hockey News" beschäftigt sich mit den zum Teil stundenlangen Verlängerungen in den NHL-Playoffs.

The OT Argument

In an era of regular changing and tweaking of hockey, there’s more and more debate on the merits of streamlining playoff overtime games so they don’t extend into a third or fourth extra frame. Senior writer Mike Brophy and senior editor Sam McCaig had to be separated when they argued the point in the office during the opening round.

SAM MCCAIG: You want intensity? Excitement? Passion? A sense of anticipation that magnifies every play? You want to sit on the edge of your seat for maybe five minutes or five hours, living and dying with every 3-on-2 and glove save and bad bounce? You want to jump up and scream and plead and cheer until you finally cry exhausted tears of double-deflection joy?

Then watch NHL playoff hockey and pray the score is tied after 60 minutes. And 100 minutes. And on and on, until endurance prevails.

Overtime should remain the same full-team game and playoff-marathon microcosm it has always been, challenging the extreme limits of clubs’ depth and heart and skill and stamina.

What are the options, anyway? Going 5-on-5 and then “tweaking” it to 4-on-4 after the first overtime? (First of all…tweak this.) Give that five years, and then watch the NHL slide down the slippery slope to 3-on-3 after the second overtime – and then it’s just one more quick tumble down to the gimmicky shootout. Never happen, you say? Regular season OT started out 5-on-5, went to 4-on-4, and then, in this Internet age of instant gratification, introduced the integrity-less shootout.

Other equally hollow arguments against 5-on-5 are that multiple overtimes take “too long,” the hockey gets “boring” and viewers “fall asleep.”

First of all, the “too long” and “boring” arguments are invalid because they’re totally subjective – one fan’s boring is another fan’s bombastic. If you care at all about either team, overtime is an agony-ecstasy shot of adrenaline. Maybe the Stars-Devils overtime games in the 2000 final weren’t a-chance-a-minute, but here’s betting Jason Arnott’s double-OT Cup-winning goal is still burned into countless brains in New Jersey. (And don’t forget, it came two days after Mike Modano scored in triple OT to extend the series.)

As far as the “too sleepy” argument…are you kidding? If you’re sleepy, do what babies do: sleep. But quit cryin’ and don’t ruin it for the rest of us.

MIKE BROPHY: As I sat there watching the San Jose Sharks and Nashville Predators skate further and further into the wee hours of the morning, with seemingly no end in sight to Game 1 of their opening round series, all I could ask myself was, why?

Why the heck was I still awake when my alarm clock was set for 6:30 a.m.? So I could wake up and start it all over again? When I couldn’t come up with a decent answer, I flipped the game off and went to sleep.

“How could you turn off such an exciting game?” senior editor Brian Costello wondered the following day.

Exciting game?

“Simple,” I said. “I closed my left eye and then I closed my right eye.”

And trust me, I was already halfway to dreamland having suffered through the first overtime period, during which the Predators outshot the Sharks 5-4. Yawn.

The crazy thing is, the Sharks-Predators game wasn’t even the longest game played that night. That honor went to the Vancouver Canucks and Dallas Stars who played an additional 78 minutes and six seconds before Henrik Sedin, of all people, put everybody out of their misery with a goal deep into the fourth OT frame.

So what can we do to end this nonsense? Simple. Play one period of 5-on-5 and then drop it to 4-on-4. No shootout. No removing another player per team after the second overtime period. Just 4-on-4 until the damn thing ends. Four-on-four overtime has become of staple of today’s regular season and while the shootout has been a godsend for eliminating tie games, there is no place for it in the playoffs. Just about everybody agrees with that.

None of this would be an issue if long overtime games were filled with end-to-end rushes and numerous scoring chances. But the majority of games that stretch beyond one overtime period become frightfully boring with an emphasis on defense.

To read the rest of this story and other great features from the world of hockey, you can buy this issue

or subscribe at

New York Rangers spielen erstmals wieder vor Zuschauern und feiern 6:2-Sieg gegen Boston
Sechster Sieg in Folge für Sturm mit Minnesota, Grubauer auf der Bank bei Avalanche-Sieg

Minnesota feiert den sechsten Erfolg hintereinander und beendet damit die Siegesserie der Los Angeles Kings von sechs Spielen. Colorado gewinnt ohne Grubauer gegen A...

Samstag: 19:00 Uhr
Calgary Flames - Ottawa Senators - mit Tim Stützle im kostenlosen Livestream

Die Ottawa Senators empfangen am Samstagabend (19 Uhr) zur besten deutschen Uhrzeit die Calgary Flames im Canadian Tire Centre. Wie ihr das Spiel kostenlos schauen k...

Minnesota Wild besiegt Colorado Avalanche
Nico Sturm trifft doppelt bei seiner Tor-Premiere

Beim vierten Sieg in Folge der Minnesota Wild versetzt Nico Sturm den Avs den endgültigen Knock-Out – seine Kollegen Mats Zuccarello und Zach Parise erreichen Meilen...

Tim Stützle mit Scorerpunkt gegen Montreal
Leon Draisaitl und Dominik Kahun brillieren bei Oilers-Sieg gegen Vancouver

Zwar weht über der Rogers Place Arena in Edmonton die kanadische Fahne, aber am Dienstagabend war der deutsche Einfluss in der westkanadischen Stadt deutlich wahrneh...

Fünfter Sieg in Folge für Co-Trainer Marco Sturm mit Los Angeles Kings
Rieder verletzt sich bei Sabres-Niederlage, Pleite für Grubauer und Sieg für Minnesota mit Sturm

Nur Nico Sturm konnte von den deutschen Akteuren einen Erfolg mit den Minnesota Wild verbuchen, während Philipp Grubauer mit Colorado gegen Vegas verliert und Tobias...

Stützle jubelt über fünften Saisonsieg mit Ottawa
Outdoor-Game: Pastrnak führt Boston mit Hattrick zu Sieg gegen Flyers

Die Boston Bruins gewinnen am Lake Tahoe das Freiluftspiel gegen die Philadelphia Flyers mit 7:3. Tim Stützle feiert Achtungserfolgt mit den Ottawa Senators gegen di...

Crosby punktet in seinem 1000. NHL-Spiel doppelt, Edmonton mit Kantersieg gegen Calgary
Outdoor-Game am Lake Tahoe: Grubauer gewinnt mit Colorado gegen Vegas trotz achtstündiger Unterbrechung

Leon Draisaitl und Dominik Kahun steuern Vorlagen bei 7:1-Sieg der Oilers bei, während Connor McDavid mit Hattrick und fünf Punkten überragt. Nico Sturm und Tobias R...

Jetzt mit Gratismonat starten!
Die NHL Live & im Replay auf DAZN

NHL Hauptrunde

Sonntag 28.02.2021
Chicago Blackhawks Chicago
3 : 5
Detroit Red Wings Detroit
Minnesota Wild Minnesota
4 : 3
Los Angeles Kings Los Angeles
Arizona Coyotes Arizona
2 : 6
Colorado Avalanche Colorado
New York Islanders NY Islanders
3 : 4
Pittsburgh Penguins Pittsburgh
Tampa Bay Lightning Tampa Bay
5 : 0
Dallas Stars Dallas
Florida Panthers Florida
3 : 4
Carolina Hurricanes Carolina
Anaheim Ducks Anaheim
2 : 3
Vegas Golden Knights Vegas
San Jose Sharks San Jose
6 : 7
St. Louis Blues St. Louis
Winnipeg Jets Winnipeg
2 : 1
Montréal Canadiens Montréal
Edmonton Oilers Edmonton
0 : 4
Toronto Maple Leafs Toronto
Nashville Predators Nashville
3 : 1
Columbus Blue Jackets Columbus
Buffalo Sabres Buffalo
0 : 3
Philadelphia Flyers Philadelphia
New York Islanders NY Islanders
2 : 0
Pittsburgh Penguins Pittsburgh
New York Rangers NY Rangers
1 : 4
Boston Bruins Boston
New Jersey Devils New Jersey
2 : 3
Washington Capitals Washington